Hey, admit it – most of us are confused about the state of the economy and housing. The increasing number of solutions and policy provided by government and through politics seem to make matters worse. There is more information out there than ever before.

In fact, it’s enough to accept the idea that ignorance really is bliss. Just ask a happy fly.

Absent of hidden agendas and built-in bias in many reporting sources, the abundance of macro data can’t lay it all out because it’s backward looking. I definitely see all of this in the coverage of real estate in the New York region and I am sure the same thing goes on in most markets.

Its less about the macro data and more about interpretation of the data to yield a coherent and reasonable picture of the future. This gets back to understanding what value is (aka housing prices) – a current perception of a future condition as it relates to a specific property.

But perception varies widely across demographics (that’s why the Dodd bill using the term “true value” is so crazy)

Education, income and party all seem to play a role in the shade of rose-colored glasses worn:

More Gallup charts here.

Baby boomers see the glass as half empty and since they are the largest demographic portion of the economy, it influences the overall media coverage on all things economic.

Since we are a consumption economy, forecasts on consumption (and it’s impact on housing or housing’s impact on consumption) tendencies might be more accurate using more warm and fuzzy indicators like the University of Michigan’s Index of Consumer Sentiment.

  • First, while most other macroeconomic data report what already happened, the ICS data report on consumers’ views about their own and the economy’s recent, current, and expected economic conditions.
  • Second, consumer attitudes may incorporate households’ estimates of the impacts of rare or even unique shocks, whose effects cannot be directly estimated from past experience or data.
  • Third, households’ answers might reflect changed expectations and uncertainties about future conditions that have not yet occurred.

But only when the economy is weak…

Consumer attitudes are more reliable as a forecasting tool when the economy is weak.

With all the flies buzzing around, I’m feeling a bit agitated (idea: that could mean greater accuracy).


2 Responses to “[Attitude Forecast Flies] Warm & Fuzzy Logic By Gloomy Or Happy Shiny People”

  1. Edd C Gillespie says:

    The term “true value” is so far undefined anywhere that I know of. The even crazier thing is that appraisers must be bonded to ensure they hit the “true value.” That might be challenge equal to the resources of Lloyd’s of London.

  2. Edd Gillespie says:

    And then we have the USPAP requirement of including the definition of value being appraised in the appraisal report. I’m sure, as resourceful as this industry has been to date that this will be nothing more than a minor glitch. The spin doctors will ride to the rescue. It must be that the guys who need help are not yet aware that they do.